Hindutva

I've finally got sucked in to writing on a controversial topic, especially during elections: Hindutva. For people who do not know, the word Hindu itself has come from a meaningless non-existing link of religion, and has come to stay to become a religion. Thats a word that will not go away, of course. The word Hindu, from the simplest trace among many similar, comes from Persians refering to us as Sindhus, those staying beyond the Sindhu river and their pronounciation of the phoneme si as hi and dhu as du. That continued to be related to the religion followed here, Sanathana Dharma (the eternal set of righteous rules, so to say) and became earmarked as Hindu, forever.

So what is sanAthana dharma? Among gazillion things, including atheism, through polytheism, to monotheism, without contradicting (surprising to people who take everything on face value), its a religion that classifies categories of people based on their work and since one usually follows work that runs in the family (a doctor's child mostly looks to be a doctor, a marwadi runs his father's business, and so on), its by birth too. A person that subscribes to this *thing* is termed a Hindu, one that voices it (me, with my trumpet!) is a Hinduvadi and this *thing* subscribed to, this *concept*, is Hindutva. With that logic, everyone can be categorized as a Hindu. Hence vasudhaiva kuTumbakam, the world is one family.

Back to political link, its all a contradictory governance, where on the one hand, brahmins are being made a singular minority in a country among a singular minority that is already made of Hindus, due to political nonsense and on the other, we voice that there shouldn't be SC, ST, OBC, untouchability and what not. For the record, there is nothing called untouchability in the Vedas, there are four classes of people, based on their birth-and-work. If its not clear, go back to basics, read them *yourself*, don't voice something that comes from polito-religious freaks who have never studied even basics, and if they have, they deliberately hide it from you in their vote-bank interest. I'll add it here for an easy look up, from the pancama veda that Mahabharata (and no, Mahabharata is not a mythological story, it is Itihaas, meaning history, and a much better recorded one, than our fake schoolbook history) is:

janmanA jAyate shUdrAh samskArAt bhavet dvijAh
veda-pAthAt bhavet vipro brahma jAnAtiti brAhmaNAh


I'm not going to write a commentary on it, but suffice it to say that everybody is a shUdrah by birth, only with values does one become a twice-born (the other three *classes* NOT *castes*), which is similar to a logic that modern education makes a person superior (yes, socially it is so; if not, why be in a society?), studying, reciting and understanding Vedas makes a person a pandit and knowing brahma (for simplicity, I'll translate this as: infinity), does one become a brAhmaNa.

Having said all that, I'll repeat, everybody is a Hindu. Finally, if that is really how great an advanced secular society we want to be, not calling ourselves Hindus, why not do two very simple things:
  1. Remove caste from all government forms and other documents.
  2. Then, remove religion from all government forms and other documents.
Whether we can do so, whether we do so, the fact that always was and will always remain is... ...vasudhaiva kuTumbakam. That has no change, na bhUto na bhavishyati.

Vande Mataram! Jai Hind!

6 comments:

GUESSWHO said...

Agree

1) Remove caste from all government forms and other documents.
2) Then, remove religion from all government forms and other documents.

Off the topic, but I would also like to have the follwing.

3) A Social Secuirty Number kind of system to track individuals.
Black money, fake accounts and terrorism activities would be controlled.
4) Force Swiss bank to disclose the accounts of Indian. I heard, Indian hold the largest amount of money than any other country. All that money would help eradicate poverty.

Advaitavedanti said...

For 3, about SSN, things were being done more than 5 yrs back and someone sensed that its not in their best interest. Don't know what happened after that, no one questions such things. The PAN card was to be the solution, but then that too remains in theory.

For 4, thats what Advani says too, but IMO, it won't help an iota of poverty here; someone else will sure take a chunk off it by the time it arrives back home. Moreover, the reason it shouldn't help Indians is the reason its out there in Switzerland in the first place.

Ameya said...

Very well written. I've debated and lectured individuals on this concept too often for my own vocal cords, and now I can simply point the ignorant to this blog entry.

Advaitavedanti said...

Thanks Ameya... means a lot to me.

Madhukara MP said...

There is also one more argument about the origin of the word Hindu and which, according to me is cprrect.

" According to the Brihaspati Agama the word 'Hindu' is formed with the letter 'Hi' from the Himalayas and 'Indu' from Indu Sarovar (the Southern Ocean), conveying the entire stretch of our motherland.
The Brihaspati Agama says:

(The land created by the gods and stretching from Himalayas to the Indu (i.e.Southern) ocean is called Hindusthan.)
The word 'Hindu' has been especially associated with us during the crucial period of the last thousand years of our history. Right from the days of Prithviraj, all our great nation-builders, statesmen, poets and historians have taken the name 'Hindu' to denote our people and our dharma. The dream of all our valiant freedom fighters like Guru Govind, Vidyaranya and Shivaji had been to establish Hindu Swaraj. The name 'Hindu' carries with it the fragrant memories of all those great lives, their deeds and their aspirations. It has thus become a word that at once reflects the unity, the sublimity and the speciality of our people."

Advaitavedanti said...

I know Gowalkar Guruji does quote that, and there are other quotes too attributed to Puranas, and even at times, Vedas. But I don't think any of it is proven. Moreover, none of our Shankara Mathadipatis quote them. There is no point in limiting ourselves to an area between Himalayas and the Indu sarovar. Even in days of Mahabharata, the area was more than that! Also, AFAIK, sarovar means river.

vasudhaiva kuTumbakam!