Yes, no one but a Sanyaasi alone can give Knowledge. Others think they can, but they can't. They keep on talking endlessly thinking thats the knowledge they're giving, but thats not knowledge. That is something that has come out of ignorance, or ego, or wrong learning, etc. This thing I'm convinced of, beyond any bit of doubt. How is it possible for anyone who's attached to give others the knowledge of detachment? One who has not renounced can't ask people to give up attachment. It has always been "Walk the talk", "practise what you preach" and "actions speak louder than words". Otherwise, its just "easier said than done".
Ramakrishna paramhamsa went up to the extent of telling people not to teach others without being directed by God to do so. He said that one needs permission from the mother to teach. Till then, one is not eligible to do so. Still, the modern day yogi, while being a bhogi, goes on and on taking people away from their followings. One of the very good indicators of a wrong guru is when s/he starts talking ill of other masters or tell people that they're on the wrong path. The true teaching will always mention of all paths leading towards the goal, in whatever capacity. A preacher who tries to convert someone else's faith (forcibly) is neither a preacher, nor has s/he understood their own dogma well. The true teaching has faith as the basis and faith comes without any qualification. It just happens. You're in the water. One can't stand on the shore and say "I'll measure the depths of the water" with the "toe in the water" principle. One has to get in the water. In fact, one doesn't have to make efforts to do so. It just happens unknowingly, more often than not, on the first sight of the water!
Then again, all of this happens only with blessings. Thence, no one has to show you the right path... what you walk, will be the right path.
om tat sat
4 comments:
Awesome
A real idealogue, that I really missed. I should be have realized the basic fact that you mentioned..
"No one but a Sannyasi" for the true seeker, who has already seen some glimpse of the truth.
Apologies
True Apologies...for having been the wrong initiator. I guess I should learn to keep my mouth shut and live with my own experiences.
It really doesn't matter....since every seeker will eventually find his/her own true path
This post was generic and I didn't have specifics to point out; all in the game :)
There's nothing to apologize; no one to apologize to!
This sounds like having some reference to some discussions you two had, wherein Hemang dared to advise your or comment on something you said. If attached cannot talk on detachment, can detached know the depths of attachment?
Take the advise on merit. A drunk can advise you not to drink based on his experience. Is not it?
But in Adhyatma, Guru imparts his self. Hence he has to be pure. Ordinary teachers can talk of precepts without practice.
Whoever said a Sanyasi gives knowledge? Rest fine.
Post a Comment